More leads often sound better than fewer, but not when poor data quality gets in the way. Businesses using identity resolution constantly navigate this balance. Volume might seem like the right answer, but it also muddies the waters with messy, repetitive, and sometimes simply incorrect data. Yet, prioritizing only the most accurate results can create data pools that are too small to be useful. 

The key is finding the right balance. When accuracy and scale are calibrated correctly, identity resolution can turn more of your website visitors into high-quality leads. In the sections that follow, we’ll look at the core challenges that make this balancing act so important and how to overcome them.

Identity Resolution Basics: Deterministic or Probabilistic

The primary objective of identity resolution is to create a unified view of each person who engages with your business. This may start with recognizing users who engage with your emails (click-based resolution), but becomes more complex when trying to identify visitors once they arrive on your website (visit-based resolution).   The challenge is that many visitors remain anonymous during their sessions, often browsing without logging in or submitting any identifying information.

Identity resolution is a powerful solution that enables you to customize the user experience and deliver relevant information that keeps visitors engaged. Understanding its limitations and how different approaches impact results is key to getting the most value from it.

Many identifiers can be used to recognize a user. These could include their login credential, email address, IP address, or browser cookies. Some of these identifiers are more likely to represent a single individual. For example, a login credential is likely to belong to one person, while an IP address could belong to a public device or one that is shared within a household.  

Identifiers that are closely tied to one person are known as deterministic. These include email address, login credentials, mobile phone number, name, and credit card numbers. Deterministic matching uses these identifiers to verify a user’s identity with a high degree of accuracy. 

By contrast, probabilistic identifiers are statistically likely to indicate an individual user. Probabilistic identity resolution typically combines multiple weaker signals such as browsing behavior, IP addresses, device type, location patterns, and cookie associations to generate a likely match. As more signals are combined, the confidence score of the match increases.

Limiting Factors of Identity Resolution

Some organizations rely on deterministic matching to maximize accuracy and ensure they are working with only verified data. However, this approach may overlook valuable leads when users cannot be definitively identified, resulting in a smaller pool of addressable prospects.

To prioritize scale, most identity resolution algorithms lean toward probabilistic matching to identify more visitors. While this expands reach, it can also introduce repetitive records, false positives, and occasional incorrect merges, where multiple individuals are mistakenly combined into a single profile. In short, probabilistic methods may improve match rates but often reduce overall data accuracy.

Neither approach on its own is sufficient to fully optimize identity resolution. Achieving the right balance between precision and scale is essential to maximize both lead volume and data quality.

The Solution to the Identity Resolution Challenge

Some identity resolution providers promote a single approach, as if all businesses face the same challenges. In reality, effective identity resolution isn’t about choosing deterministic or probabilistic methods, but about finding the right balance between the two.

Blending both approaches allows you to maximize the strengths of each while minimizing their limitations. The optimal balance depends on your specific business model, goals, and audience behavior.

Unfortunately, many vendors rely on one-size-fits-all solutions that offer limited visibility into match rates, confidence levels, or overall precision. Without transparent measurement and control, it’s difficult to know how well your system is truly identifying your audience.

The good news is that identity resolution doesn’t have to be a black box. With the right partner, you gain transparency into the entire process and the flexibility to calibrate your strategy based on your business needs.

Transparency in Identity Resolution Algorithms

For a deeper look at how Launch Labs calibrates identity resolution to meet the unique needs of each business, download our white paper on Optimizing Accuracy and Reach in Identity Graphs.

Launch Labs Enterprise Data Solutions offers a flexible, transparent approach to identity resolution designed for businesses that need both scale and precision. We help organizations find the optimal balance between reach and accuracy by allowing fine-tuned control over key resolution parameters, all backed by measurable performance data.

With every adjustment, you gain real-time visibility into how changes impact match rates, attribution, and overall data quality. This allows us to build a resolution strategy tailored to your specific goals, whether you're looking to identify more users, strengthen attribution models, or minimize misidentification risks.

{{cta4}}